TL;DR
Turn the school run and nap time into listening time
- Thousands of audiobooks, podcasts and originals
- Listen on your phone, tablet or Echo — also offline
- Cancel anytime
A MadeForMums report outlines five possible signs of oversharing, including regretting a disclosure, sharing intensely with new acquaintances and posting personal details while upset. Counselor Steven Buchwald recommends pausing, considering the audience and making room for reciprocal conversation; the signs are guidance, not a diagnosis.
MadeForMums has published a guide to recognizing when personal disclosures may be getting ahead of a relationship or a person’s comfort level, with advice from Steven Buchwald, managing director of Manhattan Mental Health Counseling. The report describes five possible signs and suggests pausing before sharing, while stressing that openness and connection do not require shutting others out.
The signs in the report include turning a casual conversation into an unusually personal exchange, feeling regret or worry afterward, filling silences with intimate details, posting personal information online while emotions are running high, and conversations that leave little room for the other person. These behaviors do not by themselves establish a problem; the report presents them as prompts to notice how sharing feels and affects a conversation.
Buchwald says people may realize after a conversation that they disclosed more than they intended. He recommends considering whether the relationship is ready for a deeply personal subject and starting with a less detailed version. If a disclosure feels urgent, writing it down or waiting before sharing may help clarify whether the person and moment are right.
For online posts, the report advises allowing time to cool off and considering whether other people, including children or partners, appear in the material. In conversation, it recommends sharing and then making space for the other person, such as by asking a genuine question and listening to the answer.
The advice addresses a common tension: people may want comfort or connection but later feel exposed after sharing more than they meant to. A pause can give someone a chance to choose the audience, timing and level of detail, rather than treating every personal thought as something that must be disclosed immediately.
The report also connects boundaries with reciprocity. When one person’s experiences dominate, a conversation may feel less balanced. Making room for another person’s response can support connection while preserving honest discussion about difficult parts of life.
How Closeness Can Build
The report draws on social penetration theory, proposed by psychologists Irwin Altman and Dalmas Taylor in 1973. The theory describes relationships as often moving from less intimate exchanges toward more personal ones over time. Buchwald applies that idea by suggesting people consider whether a relationship has reached the stage for a particular disclosure.
Online sharing presents a separate timing challenge because posts and messages can be sent quickly. The report cites a 2012 Pew Research Center survey in which 11% of surveyed social media profile owners said they had posted something they later regretted; the figure was 15% among respondents aged 18 to 29. Those figures describe that survey at that time and do not establish current rates.
“Social media rewards immediacy. But emotional material often needs a cooling-off period. What feels urgent at midnight can look very different in the morning.”
— Steven Buchwald
When Sharing Feels Too Much
The report offers practical signs, but it does not define a clinical threshold for oversharing or establish that any single behavior is harmful. Feeling regret, speaking personally or posting about one’s life can have different meanings depending on a person, relationship and situation. The source also does not provide a publication date, and its cited social media figures are from 2012, so they should not be read as current estimates.
Pause Before the Next Disclosure
The report’s suggested next step is a brief check-in before sharing: consider what response is wanted, whether this person is the right audience, and how much detail feels comfortable. If the conversation is already underway, a lighter topic, a question to the other person or a moment of silence can restore balance.
For a personal post, waiting until the next day may provide perspective. Buchwald suggests that if someone is seeking comfort or advice, they can say so directly; if they mainly want to release anxiety, a journal, trusted friend or therapist may be a more suitable outlet. These are options in the report, not a substitute for individualized mental health care.
Key Questions
What are the five signs of oversharing in the report?
They are disclosing very personal details in a casual conversation, regretting a disclosure afterward, using intimate stories to fill silence, posting personal material online while emotions are high, and conversations that become one-sided.
Does sharing personal details mean someone is oversharing?
No single disclosure proves that. The report frames its signs as reasons to reflect on whether the person, timing and level of detail felt right.
How can someone pause without becoming closed off?
Consider what you hope to get from sharing, start with less detail if unsure, and give the other person room to respond. The report presents these steps as ways to stay open while choosing how and when to share.
What does the report say about social media posts?
It recommends waiting before publishing highly personal material when emotions are running high and considering whether other people included in a post would be comfortable with it.
Source: rss
Fall Picks
fall essentials
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
